Not Your Job to Keep a Man Faithful: Red Flags Behind “He’s a Good Catch” Claims

A guy posted in a Facebook group: “Ladies, I am a good catch. I am gainfully employed, family‑oriented, driven, adventurous and faithful if you give me a reason to be.”
I read “if you give me a reason to be” about seven times before I registered the red flag. Women in the group ripped him apart. Some men chimed in, insisting it’s the woman’s job to keep a man loyal.

Here’s what needs to be clear: no matter how amazing you are, some men cheat anyway.

Let’s break it down:

The One‑Timer
This person isn’t unhappy—they’re usually content. But when something missing or a random opportunity appears, they slip. It might feel like “grass is greener,” and they falter. Most one‑timers regret it immediately and don’t repeat the behavior. They usually appreciate forgiveness and want to prove they can do better.

The Unhappy Camper
They may feel neglected—emotionally or physically. Maybe stress, exhaustion, or distance in the relationship drives them away. Instead of addressing issues together, they look elsewhere for validation. They may think the fix is outside the relationship.

The “It’s Just Sex” Cheater
Loves their partner, maybe, but craves new sexual experiences. No emotional connection, just physical satisfaction. Conscience might ping them, but discipline lacks. Sometimes both partners know and agree; other times infidelity happens without consent. It’s not love, it’s impulse.

The Emotional Two‑Timer
This is often the most painful betrayal. A second relationship involves sharing feelings, hopes, and intimacy. They come home to you, but they lean on someone else emotionally. They want “two sides” of life: excitement and comfort. Let both parties exist until something changes. Often, emotional involvement outlasts the physical.

The Narcissist
Full of charm and attention seekers. They cheat openly—or reveal it in ways to provoke reaction. Empathy is foreign to them. Your tears or anger are inconveniences. They believe loyalty is optional and blame you when things go south. They feed off admiration and attention from anyone who shows interest.

The One Who Cheats to Exit
They’re over the relationship but unwilling to have the tough conversation. So they engineer betrayal, hoping you’ll leave them first. It’s intentional self‑sabotage disguised as infidelity.

None of these types of cheating happen because of something you did—or failed to do. They come from the person cheating, not the partner they betray. You can’t prevent infidelity with effort. True faithfulness isn’t negotiated—it’s decided. If someone says it’s your job to keep them in line, respect, or faithful, they’re shifting responsibility for their actions onto you. That’s unfair and invalid.

Your worth isn’t in fixing someone else’s character flaws. Cheating isn’t about you—it’s about their integrity.